How Could You? Hall of Shame-Dino Cardelli UPDATED

This will be an archive of heinous actions by those involved in child welfare, foster care and adoption. We forewarn you that these are deeply disturbing stories that may involve sex abuse, murder, kidnapping and other horrendous actions.

From Eureka, California, ex-Pastor and foster father Dino Cardelli, 50, “has pleaded guilty to charges that he sexual abused two girls, including one who was placed in his care.”

He “entered his plea Monday to sex abuse and molestation charges as well as 25 counts of violating a court order to not contact the victims.

Cardelli was pastor of Arcata’s evangelical Calvary Chapel for 15 years. He resigned after he was arrested last September.

Authorities say a 13-year-old foster child who lived in his McKinleyville home reported the abuse at her school. Prosecutors later identified a second victim.

Cardelli violated the court order when he used a prepaid cell phone and a fake Facebook page to contact one of the girls.

Ex-Humboldt pastor pleads guilty to sex abuse
[The Sacramento Bee 6/23/11 by Associated Press]

“Deputy District Attorney Kelly Neel said the law requires Cardelli to go through what is commonly referred to as a “psycho-sexual” evaluation for the court’s consideration prior to sentencing.

The next hearing in the case is set for July 18.

After the former pastor at Calvary Chapel was arrested in September, the prosecution charged him with three counts of lewd and lascivious behavior with a child under 14 years old, seven counts alleging there were multiple victims in the case, two counts of oral copulation with a child under 16, recurring sexual conduct with a victim under 14 and a special allegation of a victim under 14. ”

Former Arcata pastor pleads guilty to sexual abuse of a minor; Sentencing hearing set for July
[The Times-Standard 6/23/11 by Donna Tam]

“In the deal, entered on Monday, Cardelli pleaded guilty to one count of continuous sexual abuse of a minor under age 14, one count of attempting to dissuade a witness, 25 misdemeanor counts of violating a court order by contacting a victim, and, regarding the second victim, a misdemeanor count of annoying or molesting a child, according to District Attorney’s Office Public Information Officer Lynette Mullen. ”

“Cardelli is scheduled to appear before Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson in mid July to address the status of his sentencing.”

Former Pastor Dino Cardelli Takes Plea Deal in Child Abuse Case
[North Coast Journal 6/22/11 by Ryan Burns]

March 2011 Article

“Former Arcata pastor Dino Cardelli was denied his request to be released on his own recognizance Monday, while Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson opted to keep the alleged child molester’s bail set at $850,000.

Cardelli, 49, pleaded not guilty in January to a slew of charges stemming from his alleged sexual relationship with a girl under the age of 14, and prosecutors in the case believe there is at least one additional victim. An array of new charges were filed against Cardelli this month, including a single felony count of attempting to dissuade a witness and more than two dozen misdemeanor counts of willful disobedience of a court order.

In December, Cardelli was given explicit orders from the court to refrain from any contact with the pair of alleged minor victims in the case, including both phone and Internet contact.

Cardelli’s attorney, Mark Bruce, said the former pastor at Calvary Chapel in Arcata should be held on a reduced bail between $300,000 and $500,000, closer to the standard $250,000 that Cardelli’s charges would generally warrant. While neither confirming nor denying the allegations that Cardelli was in contact with one of the alleged victims in the case, Bruce urged the court to consider that the bulk of messages prosecutors produced as evidence were responses from messages Cardelli received from the victim.”

“Prosecutors are alleging that Cardelli created a false Facebook account under a different name and that he initiated contact with the victim with messages, including one that read: “I will never leave you, all the days of your life I will find a way to be in contact with you until we can be together again.”

Neel said that while Cardelli has not been convicted of any charges, he faces significant time in prison if he is found guilty, and that bail remains set at $850,000 — $100,000 of which stems from the new charges.

”This has been enormously difficult on the victim and her family,” Neel said. “For him to be out of custody again gives him full access to her. Mr. Cardelli simply cannot be trusted to abide by the terms of his release.”
Dino Cardelli denied release on own recognizance; prosecution alleges continued contact with alleged sexual abuse victim through Facebook
[The Times-Standard 3/1/11 by Matt Drange]

For a blog discussion on Calvary Chapel abuse, read Calvary Chapel Abuse blog

For the rest of the information about this case that began in September 2010, read Pound Pup Legacy Cardelli Files

REFORM Puzzle Pieces

Update: “Last week, a judge in Humbolt County sentenced Dino Cardelli to the maximum sentence allowed–18 years–for molesting his two stepdaughters. ”

Dino Cardelli, Former Calvary Chapel Pastor in Arcata, Convicted of Molesting Stepdaughters

[OC Weekly 8/30/11 by Gustavo Arellano]

“Despite a former Arcata pastor’s pleas for probation, a Humboldt County Superior Court judge sentenced Dino Cardelli to the maximum prison sentence allowable Monday, charging that he essentially seduced his adopted daughter with Bible passages in order to molest her.

Arrested last September, Cardelli, 50, pleaded guilty June 22 to charges of the continual sexual abuse of a minor, child molestation, attempting to dissuade a witness and 25 counts of violating a court order not to contact his victim.

During an emotional two-hour court hearing, the court heard from one of two victims in the case — identified as Jane Doe 1 — and from Cardelli, and attorneys debated an appropriate sentence for Cardelli, who — until his arrest — had served as the pastor of Arcata’s Calvary Chapel. He and his late wife opened the church in January 1995.

Judge Bruce Watson sentenced Cardelli to serve 18 years in prison, the maximum allowable under a plea agreement Cardelli reached with prosecutors the day his trial was slated to begin. Watson said he weighed both mitigating and aggravating factors in reaching an appropriate sentence for Cardelli but said the scale tilted heavily toward handing down the maximum sentence.

Watson said Cardelli took advantage of a vulnerable victim, a girl he’d adopted at the age of 5 and who was 13 when the acts of molestation began. The judge said Cardelli then repeatedly attempted to dissuade Jane Doe 1 from cooperating in the case. Watson said the former pastor also betrayed the trust and confidence of his daughter, his community and his congregation.

”He violated the trust of countless people,” Watson said.

A probation report in the case, quoted by Watson, also indicates that the pastor used the Bible to convince Jane Doe 1 to acquiesce to his advances.

”He talked her into a sexual relationship by reading her passages from the Bible he interpreted as condoning it,” Watson read from the report before later opining about it. “It seems very disturbing, as a pastor, to be using the Bible to induce the victim to participate — in essence seducing her with Bible passages.”

Under the terms of the sentence Watson handed down Monday, Cardelli will serve at least 85 percent of his 18-year prison sentence, will be put on supervised parole for 20 years after his release and will have to register as a sex offender for life.

Cardelli’s attorney M.C. Bruce repeatedly asked for a sentencing postponement and said after the hearing that his client plans to appeal the sentence.

When Jane Doe 1 addressed the court, she said Cardelli’s decisions led to her being separated from her brothers and sisters. She said she also carries the burden of Nancy Cardelli’s suicide, which occurred after the mother told numerous people she suspected her husband was having an inappropriate relationship with Jane Doe 1, then 13.

”I have felt much of the blame for my mother’s death, and I’ve carried it too long,” Jane Doe 1 said, adding that she’s contemplated suicide and that her innocence is gone. “It was not fair for the man who was supposed to be my father to take that away from me.”

Jane Doe 1 went on to say she will always love both her parents, including her father, who she said taught her how to “be a loving, virtuous woman of God, but I will never respect the decisions he made.”

In addressing the court, Dino Cardelli — who showed no emotion during Jane Doe 1’s remarks — apologized to his family and especially to his victim.

”My actions caused this travesty and these horrible events,” he said, adding that his wrongdoing had also hurt the community and his church body. “I know what I’ve done is a horrible thing that’s happened, and I know it’s something that my daughter will have to live with for the rest of her life.”

Dino Cardelli displayed little emotion throughout his remarks, but choked up when describing how Jane Doe 1 will have to tell her future husband of the secrets in her past.

The former pastor asked that he be released on probation, saying he wanted to seek treatment and rejoin his community and that he posed no risk of re-offending.

In addressing the court, Bruce argued that — if not probation — his client should be sentenced to the minimum term of incarceration allowable under the deal.

”A sentence of eight years gives Jane Doe plenty enough time to grow and forget,” Bruce said. [Say what?]

The defense attorney further argued that much of the pain and stress experienced by Jane Doe 1 was due to media reporting of the case, saying his client had no control over what was written about her or what “newspapers have done to ruin her life.”

Bruce further argued that it is there is no evidence to connect Nancy Cardelli’s suicide with the sexual relationship between her husband and her daughter.

”To inject that into this proceeding is a disservice to everyone,” he said, adding that Dino Cardelli and his wife were also going through emotional difficulties and marriage problems at the time Cardelli began his relationship with Jane Doe 1.

Prosecuting Assistant District Attorney Kelly Neel argued that Dino Cardelli groomed a vulnerable little girl whom he’d adopted at the age of 5 to be the victim of his sexual advances. She said he’s repeatedly failed to take responsibility for this, preferring to view his molestation simply as a romantic relationship. In the weeks before his arrest, Neel said, Dino Cardelli also molested another of his adopted daughters on three separate occasions.

Given the chance after posting bail in the case, Neel said, Dino Cardelli tried to talk Jane Doe 1 out of cooperating with authorities.

”What Mr. Cardelli can’t deny is that he had ongoing sexual contact with a minor under the age of 14,” Neel said. “… The defendant, throughout these proceedings, has seemed to see this abuse — what he was doing to this little girl — as a romantic relationship.”

Ultimately, Neel said, Dino Cardelli left his daughters to carry this burden, for which there are no mitigating circumstances.

”What possible mitigating circumstances could there be for a 50-year-old man to molest his daughter? To molest two of his daughters?” she asked.

Cardelli gets 18 years in molestation case

[Eureka Times Standard 8/23/11 by Thaddeus Greenson]